Intuition
Two topologies sit at the ends of the range. One declares every subset open, the other admits only the two the axioms force. Every other topology lies between them.
A camera with the finest grain records every speck; one with the coarsest sees a single block of colour. Both are pictures of the same scene, at the two ends of what can be told apart.
The two extremes, and comparing topologies
The discrete topology on is , the collection of all subsets: everything is open. The indiscrete topology is : only what the first axiom forces. If then is called finer and coarser, because the finer one can tell more sets apart.
What the extremes look like
- Both are genuinely topologies: every axiom is satisfied by each, and in the discrete case for trivial reasons.
- The discrete topology is the one chapter one’s 0-or-1 distance produces, since makes every single point open.
- In the indiscrete topology the only open set holding a given point is the whole space, so no two points can be told apart by open sets.
- Finer and coarser only compare two topologies on the same set, and two topologies need not be comparable at all.
Not every topology comes from a metric
Suppose the indiscrete topology on a set with at least two points were the collection of open sets of some distance. Take two different points. Their distance is a positive number, so the ball around the first with that radius is an open set holding the first point and missing the second. It is neither empty nor the whole space, so it is an open set the indiscrete topology has not got. That is the contradiction, and it shows the axioms describe strictly more spaces than distances do.
Proof steps
The set has at least two points, so two different ones can be chosen.
Their distance cannot be zero: chapter one’s first condition says distance zero means the same point.
The centre is always in its own ball, and is not, because is not less than .
The ball is open, is not empty and is not everything, so the metric produces an open set the indiscrete topology does not contain.
Applications
Practice
Discrete: everything is open
All four subsets, all of them open.
Try it
In the discrete topology on , which subsets are open?
Everything lies between
The range within which every topology on falls.
Try it
Which topology on is the coarsest?
A metric always separates two points
The second point is exactly excluded, since the ball is strict.
Try it
Why does no metric produce the indiscrete topology on a set of two points?
Finer means more open sets
Neither contains the other: not every pair can be compared.
Try it
If , which is finer?
Try it
How many topologies are there on , a set with one point?
Try it
On an infinite set, where does the cofinite topology sit between the two extremes?
Try it
Two topologies on the same set are always comparable: one of them is finer.
Try it
Which metric produces the discrete topology on a set?